Comments on: Circumcision – An Idea Whose Time Has Passed

By: RodC

RodC — Wed, 26 Sep 2012 09:41:14 +0000

I have read that in the three oldest existing copies of the Torah that circumcision is not mentioned as being part of the covenant between God and Abraham – and that the rite of circumcision was inserted ca.500BC
(1000 years after Abraham) by Jewish priests. I do not have the reference to this claim. Has anyone else come across it? If true, it rather knocks out the claim for it to be a required religious rite.

By: Charles Traynor

Charles Traynor — Sat, 22 Sep 2012 14:32:29 +0000

Another great show,Carolyn. Mutilating the genitals of children has never been a part of Western culture. It would, therefore, be interesting to learn where and when Americans first began practicing this barbaric custom.

Link to a horrific news article about Rabbis spreading herpes to Jewish babies in New York:

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/03/06/baby-dies-circumcision-ritual-herpes_n_1322420.html

By: Alexander from Flanders

Alexander from Flanders — Fri, 21 Sep 2012 05:09:19 +0000

I’m from Belgium (Flemish part) and circumcision here is viewed very different than in the US. Every professional doctor will tell you here that it is bad for your health and sex life. Anyone who claims otherwise is simply lying.

It is quite a shock to me to learn that circumcision is so common amongst non jews in the US. And even more shocking that people still believe the lies told by the disgusting American doctors. What a bunch of freaks!

By the way; here is a link to a catholic website from Belgium with some info. The title is “Discouragement of circumcision”. I’m not a christian but at least they are right on this subject. It was posted because of the controversy in Germany. So Caroline is right: We should use this in our advancement. People are talking about this.

http://www.katholieknieuwsblad.nl/opinie/item/2423-ontmoedig-besnijden-van-jongens.html

PS. Caroline you’re show is AWESOME. Keep up the good work!!

By: Brit in Norway

Brit in Norway — Thu, 20 Sep 2012 12:12:29 +0000

As you said Carolyn, this whole circumcision business is just awful. I thought you covered many areas and IMO you brought out just how important this topic is in dealing with the Jewish menace. A few points I’d read are: some Christian sources state early circumcision was only removing the tip of the foreskin. It changed with the pharisees. I’m not
sure how true this is though. I know Traditional Catholics and Eastern Orthodox see it as “a wound” which is a healthier mentality. I believe when surgery is medically required it is usually best achieved by a frenectomy not circumcision. Personally, I believe the practice is insane from our perspective and akin to how the orthodox Jews swing chickens over their heads when they pray. The origins of it though are important to study which you did go into. Everyone needs to attack them on this as they clearly are struggling to justify it.

By: Carolyn

Carolyn — Wed, 19 Sep 2012 21:01:38 +0000

NEW STATS! I was able to look at my carolynyeager.com server stats today for August and September (to date) and found the downloads had improved. I knew the traffic at my site was up, but didn’t know how much. This program on circumcision has 343 dls, plus 102 here at The White Network, adding up to 445 in all since Monday night (about 40 hours). However, my server stats include all hits, while tWn count is restricted to completed downloads only. If it were not, its numbers would be considerably higher.

I’m bringing this up because of what was said on the previous week’s Heretics’ Hour that we had “about 1000” on average per show. Dietrich was citing server “hits” in his figures, not full downloads as Tan does at tWn.

Here are some numbers on other Sept. shows: the “Libel, Slander” with Bill Finck Saturday Afternoon with Carolyn show on Sept. 1st has 3,039 dls to date (19 days) plus 325 on tWn. Sept. 8th (Dietrich – Crossed Signals) has 1607 to date plus 302 at tWn; and Sept 15 (John Beattie) has 782, plus 186 at tWn.

The Sept. 3rd Heretics’ Hour (Elie Wiesel and Gottfried Feder) has 2605 dls to date (16 days), plus 196 at tWn. Sept. 10th HH (Dietrich – Mishko) is at 1400, and 297 at tWn.

The International Jew Study Hour, Episode 10 has had 2355 downloads since Aug. 30 (20 days) plus 181 at tWn.

I think I will study this some more and post a blog on it soon.

By: Nick Dean

Nick Dean — Wed, 19 Sep 2012 08:36:25 +0000

In general I think the comments section at the Occidental Observer has been a disaster (in terms of quality and subsequent PR), but there was one especially active fella in a thread about this topic and he posted quite a lot of interesting stuff. Should be easy to google up for those interested.

By: Mary, White Advocate

Mary, White Advocate — Tue, 18 Sep 2012 22:32:41 +0000

A Russian emigre told me that the reason the Jews pushed and almost enforced circumcision in the USA is so that “they can’t tell them (the Jews) apart.” This is very true. One will never see this in history books or hear about it on the History Channel, but about every hundred years or so the Jews have been expelled from every duchy, city state, kingdom, dukedom, barony, country, province, etc., in Europe. One could ask, how does one tell them apart from the rest of the population, especially in Southern European countries like Italy and Spain? The answer is that the men were lined up at spear/sword/gun point and told to drop their trousers and drawers. The men who had been circumcised were taken away and either shot or rounded up with their families and expelled from the area.

I have seen pictures of circumcisions and those photographs belong in a police evidence file to be used at the trial of a sex criminal. I would like to see this brutal and cruel practice be outlawed in every country in the world.

By: Carl

Carl — Tue, 18 Sep 2012 22:23:42 +0000

Agreed! 🙂

By: Carolyn

Carolyn — Tue, 18 Sep 2012 17:15:34 +0000

Whether Mr. Finck agrees with what I said about the spread of Christianity to ‘all the nations’ is not the point here, Carl. The point is what we do about circumcision today, with the opportunity we have. I hope we can keep up some effort in that direction without getting sidetracked. Thanks for the great article updating the cause of low sperm counts in Israel. That’s incredible news.

By: Carolyn

Carolyn — Tue, 18 Sep 2012 17:08:32 +0000

Check this out for what the medical profession gets away with: http://www.cbc.ca/news/background/reimer/

“The Boy Who Lived as a Girl” after a botched circumcision. My thanks to a listener for this.